The same, great seats, year after year—by subscribing to 3 or more mainstage shows, subscribers get the same seats for each performance in their package. Packages are built around a chosen day of the week and a specific week of performances to ensure the same seats are available. Subscribers may add as many seats as they wish to their package, as long as each seat is added to at least 3 different shows.
Dates are automatically assigned to subscription packages to ensure seating. Subscribers are encouraged to make use of their unlimited free exchanges to find comparable seating on their preferred dates after their package has been processed.
Subscribers may utilize our ticket exchange form to request an exchange for their tickets. Our staff will work to find comparable seating to your original locations, though an exact match is not guaranteed.
Ticket Exchange Form
Exchanges can be made until 3:00 PM the day of an evening performance or by 5:00 PM the day before a matinee. Exchanges requested after these deadlines or after the originally scheduled performance has passed are subject to our Missed Performance Policy.
Subscribers who have missed the exchange deadline or their scheduled mainstage performance may arrange for tickets to a new performance of the same mainstage production by calling Ticketing & Audience Services one business day before the desired new performance. New tickets will not be available for rescheduling if calling any earlier or later than one business day before the desired new performance.
Missed tickets are subject to availability, and some restrictions may apply.
Bring your friends and family! Subscribers receive a range of discounts on additional mainstage tickets. Subscriber ID must be provided at the time of purchase. Discounts exclude price section D. Benefits are subject to restrictions and availability and cannot be combined with any other offers.
20% Subscriber Discount
All Subscribers receive 20% off the standard rate for additional tickets.
$40 Bring-a-Friend Tickets
4- and 5-Show Subscribers receive two $40 Bring-a-Friend tickets for each seat in their subscription.
Bring-a-Friend tickets expire at the end of the current season and must be redeemed by contacting Ticketing & Audience Services.
50% Youth Discount
5-Show Subscribers receive 50% off the standard rate for additional tickets for children aged 4-18. Youth tickets may be purchased by contacting Ticketing & Audience Services.
In addition to great seats as part of their subscription, subscribers also receive an early presale opportunity to purchase additional tickets to our mainstage season for friends and family before the general public. As an added bonus, handling fees are waived during this presale period for the mainstage season!
Subscribers also receive priority access to Paper Mill events, including our summer Brookside Cabaret, before they are made available to the general public.
Beginning with the 2023–2024 season, subscribers will receive invitations to new and exciting subscriber-exclusive events such as backstage tours, live tapings of our Director’s Viewpoint podcast, and the season announcement for the following year!
NEW SPECIAL EVENTS FOR SUBSCRIBERS:
- FALL SUBSCRIBER OPEN HOUSE
Subscribers are invited for a backstage tour and reception on Saturday, September 9,
from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM. RSVP required. An email will be sent when reservations are open.- Single-Seat Meet & Greet
We have heard that some single-seat subscribers would like to connect with others interested in attending shows together. We encourage those subscribers to come to the theater at 10:00 AM this day for a special meet-and-greet.
- Single-Seat Meet & Greet
- INVITATIONS TO LIVE TAPINGS OF DIRECTOR’S VIEWPOINT
Producing Artistic Director Mark S. Hoebee will interview each of the production’s directors, and subscribers will be invited to attend these live tapings. Space is limited. RSVP required. An email will be sent when reservations are open. (Dates and times are subject to change)- The Great Gatsby: October 12, 2023, 5:30 PM
- Fiddler on the Roof: December 6, 2023, 5:30 PM
- After Midnight: January 31, 2024, 5:30 PM
- Gun & Powder: April 4, 2024, 5:30 PM
- Beautiful: The Carole King Musical: June 5, 2024, 5:30 PM
Subscribers have the ability to make reservations at the Carriage House Restaurant at the F.M. Kirby Carriage House before it is made available to the general public. Reservations are available for subscribers now for the 2023-2024 season! Secure your reservations before they are made available to the general public on August 14.
